High Noon
Two products. Same criteria. One winner called at the end. No "it depends." If it depends, we tell you on what, and then we still call it.
The rules of the duel
Both products go through the same Carry Test, side by side, same week, same belt. Same criteria written down before we start, so the loser can't say we moved the goalposts.
Scoring
Five criteria, chosen per category. Each is a round. The product with more rounds wins. Ties go to the cheaper one, because your money matters more than our pride.
The Sundown Showdown
A new one every Friday, in the Dispatch before it hits the site. Readers pick next week's matchup in The Posse.
Want to see two products fight?
Tell us the matchup. The Posse votes every Friday on what we test next.